Now I'm leaning towards a set of logos that's a little simpler, to reflect a 'handmade' aesthetic.
The problem is, I like them both, which isn't a bad problem to have, really. I suspect I'll go with the newest logo set, because I think it will be more versatile, and it will age better. And I think it better communicates what I want my brand to be. I don't know, what do you think? The key words that I'm using to guide me are 'comfortable,' 'approachable,' 'sweet,' 'happy,' and 'handmade.